Ask Ben Character
ask
ben
All brandsHow it works
Homepage
Brands
italianshoemakers-com

Explore

  • Brands A-Z

Company

  • How it works
  • About Yotpo
Ben
By
    Ben
    By

    Explore

    • Brands A-Z

    Company

    • How it works
    • About Yotpo

      Site reviews

      How we present the reviews
      Anonymous user
      Jessica A.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      High quality shoes

      Excellent craftsmanship and customer service. Delivery was timely and accurate. I hope these shoes will last as long as the previous pair I owned from this company.

      SEP 11, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Yoli P.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      2 out of 5 stars

      Size did not fit. I

      Size did not fit. I tried to return online and one the last step got a message that an error occurred and couldn't print return tag. It said to try again later. When l tried again got a message saying "Unavailable for return" because item had already been returned. I would greatly appreciate either receiving a return tag by mail, or at least a mailing address where l can return the shoes.

      SEP 7, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Paula C.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Favorite brand of shoes

      Great shoes and they arrived quickly.

      SEP 2, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Christine B.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      1 out of 5 stars

      Fell apart

      The first time I wore my new shoes, the sole lining shredded in several places. I've been wearing this brand for years. So disappointed with the quality of materials. I would really like a full refund.

      AUG 29, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Lynn A.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      I would buy shoes from

      I would buy shoes from Italian Shoemakers again! My daughter loves her shoes

      AUG 26, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Cheryl S.🇯🇲
      Verified Buyer
      1 out of 5 stars

      Re My Order 20512

      The Missie Thong Sandal received is the wrong size. I ordered size 9 . I got 9 /12. Its too big. I think its defective s I wore it ONCE and both feet of the sandals were torn. Im requesting either a replacement OR full credit . asap Cheryl Strachan 876-870-6404

      AUG 25, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Donna M.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Love, Love, Love italian shoemaker

      Love, Love, Love italian shoemaker shoes

      AUG 15, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Cynthia G.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Every aspect of the experience

      Every aspect of the experience was good

      AUG 15, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Colleen P.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Great summer sandals! Fit, quality

      Great summer sandals! Fit, quality and comfort-perfect! Have the Berty in black and navy. Arrived quickly-right to my door! Love Italian Shoemakers!!!

      AUG 10, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Evelyn B.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      1 out of 5 stars

      Dirty shoes

      I have emailed 4 times for a return label and still haven’t received one. So I am not happy with the dirty shoes that were sent to me and they don’t even do what I asked for.

      AUG 7, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Christine O.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      1 out of 5 stars

      I have emailed your customer

      I have emailed your customer service department four times with no response. I need a return label for my shoes. It is not printing out on my end and said there is an error on your end however, I get no response but you send me this. Please contact me.

      AUG 4, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Rebecca D.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      2 out of 5 stars

      Customer Service doesnt respond

      I placed my first order but tried repeatedly to get the 10% discount that is displayed as a banner on the site. Ive sent an email to customer service twice about it but they never responded.

      AUG 4, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Julie F.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Italian Roots

      True Italian style with femininity comfort, affordability.

      AUG 4, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Christine M.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Beautiful shoe

      I bought these shoes to wear with a Sari for a wedding. Color of shoes match perfectly. Has a small heel to give me some height (I am 5'2") but not too much too be uncomfortable. So happy I bought these!!

      AUG 2, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Rona K.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      2 out of 5 stars

      They never answered any emails

      They never answered any emails and there is no phone number with your order. When you try to finish your return, it does not generate a return label and says to email them. I had to scour the Internet to find the phone number and then they emailed me a return label. Way too much effort needed.

      JUL 30, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Barbara H.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Love these! Cute and comfy

      Love these! Cute and comfy 😊

      JUL 24, 2025
      Anonymous user
      bonnie z.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      So easy to order online

      So easy to order online and I love the free shipping!

      JUL 23, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Katherine B.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      5 out of 5 stars

      Great Products and Shopping Experience

      Placed two orders which arrived quickly and nicely packaged. The shoes are affordable, exactly as advertised, stylish, true to size, and very comfortable. I will definitely shop with Italian Shoemakers again!

      JUL 21, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Laurel W.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      1 out of 5 stars

      Customer Service

      I have reached out through email, through online chat and have not heard back from Italian shoemakers. I continually receive marketing email and requests for feedback but cannot get any information back.

      JUL 21, 2025
      Anonymous user
      Jodie S.🇺🇸
      Verified Buyer
      3 out of 5 stars

      Best high wedge/heel padded footbed sandals

      One out of three pairs fit really well. All of the Italian shoemakers shoes used to be highly padded comfort footbed shoes and now only some are. That was the beauty of Italian shoemakers. You have to make sure you know what you are buying. Every shoe is made differently and the consistency is no longer. I love Italian shoemakers shoes and will continue buying them forever. I hope they keep making the extra comfort high wedge and heel padded footbed sandals. I can’t survive without them.

      JUL 19, 2025
      12345

      More brands you might like

      Natural Life - Shopify brand image
      clothing,fashion & accessories

      Natural Life - Shopify

      View brand|Shop brand
      Rating
      4.9
      Total Reviews
      502.2K
      http://velvetcaviar.com brand image
      clothing,fashion & accessories

      http://velvetcaviar.com

      View brand|Shop brand
      Rating
      4.9
      Total Reviews
      237.6K
      http://paireyewear.com brand image
      clothing,fashion & accessories

      http://paireyewear.com

      View brand|Shop brand
      Rating
      4.9
      Total Reviews
      234.5K
      Italian Shoemakers logo

      Italian Shoemakers

      clothing,fashion & accessories
      4.4
      |
      569
      Visit online store
      Italian Shoemakers logo

      Italian Shoemakers

      clothing,fashion & accessories
      4.4
      |
      569
      Visit online store
      4.4
      4.4 out of 5 stars
      Based on 569 reviews
      5
      430
      4
      37
      3
      30
      2
      17
      1
      55
      Ratings distribution data table
      StarsCount
      5430
      437
      330
      217
      155
      Total569