Bought the snickerdoodle/cheesecake And Reeses Monster and holy cow. The Reeses is phenomenal! Fresh , packaged perfectly for the heat. They were prob chilled as it felt cool and def not melted in the hot temp. Will be looking for you in Nyack. Im not even going to gripe about the lack of calorie count because I would have eaten it anyway. But maybe something to consider in the future.

Cookies arrived well packaged and with a cute little duck. Each individually wrapped and labeled. The ingredients and calories are not listed on each cookie. This was a big issue for me as an athlete who tracks food I need to know portions and control sugars. The cookies are super sweet beyond what a normal cookie sweetness is. I cannot recommend this brand due to lack of information on what is being consumed (ingredients)

So far we have loved every cookie with a filling. We are deciding on our favorites and will order them.

Fantastic

The cookie is excellent! It is perfect. The size, the taste. It is unique and find it so decadent and delicious. The disappointment came with the packaging. It didn’t match the experience of the cookie. It brings it down. That is disappointing. It needs to be upgraded to elevate it to match how special and good the cookie is. It felt I ordered cookies from a private home, not an established business. I would not order to offer them as a gift for that matter. Also, all the plastic toys inside the box went straight to the garbage bin. It is a waste. Not necessary. Best of luck. You have something great to built with. Martin

Wonderful cookies fast service very high-quality. You guys are amazing. Thank you for making gluten-free options too.

The cookies are incredible and like nothing else. The packaging was so fun to open with all the little toys thrown in! Loved it!

With just a look at me you can see that I have eaten a lot of cookies in my lifetime, and I can say, without reservation, that aside from my grandmother's cookies, I have never eaten a better cookie than an insideout cookie. I would have given this 6 stars if available. As one suggestion for future cookie ideas, you could cover some in frosting and really blow people's minds, your cookie design lends itself to a cupholder of frosting that could be next level amazing and could also cause instant diabetes.

Delicious.

My order was confirmed, shipped, and arrived within 72 hrs. These cookies are AMAZING!!! I've frozen some of them and they maintain their quality despite having been frozen for several weeks. Would give them 6 out of 5 stars if I could!

it was really good, problem is my plan of 1 cookie a day turned into 2 and before i knew it i ate $60 worth of cookies

Bought a Dubai Chocolate cookie at the Lewisburg Arts Festival today. The most incredible cookie. Think death by Chocolate lava cake with a middle eastern twist. So good.

Best cookies I’ve ever had. Snickerdoodle cheesecake was unbelievable!

The cookies were all delicious, I would absolutely order again and I would have given 5 stars all day but they forgot a cookie (I ordered online and had shipped) I sent an email out letting them know but never even got a response, luckily the cookies are good enough I'll let that slip.

The cookies were delicious and disappeared quickly. Good value for money!

OMG! These cookies are AMAZING! Seriously the best!! I stumbled upon your Instagram page two night’s ago and spontaneously placed an order. They arrived today. I highly recommend and I will definitely order again in the future.

Delicious!!!

Fantastic product! Found them at Happy Valley Comicon in 2024. Ordered a box to tuck into Easter baskets this year — quality & flavor are unmatched!

I ordered a dozen cookies and was missing one. I emailed twice and was told that there was an issue with the bakery and they weren’t able to make that cookie. They asked me if I wanted a credit or the cookie. I said to please send me the missing cookie. I have yet to receive the missing cookie.

Website was difficult to navigate as was tracking of my order. When I tried to call for support no one ever returned my call or emails. Cookies did arrive.