The Carmel stuffed pecan pie cookie is our favorite, with the Dubai chocolate as a runnerup. My son loves the extreme peanut butter one. The lemon one let us down. I Was hoping for a strong lemon flavor but it was a mild flavor.

I was at the apple festival in Ithaca this past weekend and happened by your booth...Yum I purchased four: stuffed Peanut Butter, Lemon and two gluten free vegan Chocolate Oreo stuffed cookies. These are like four cookies each and so good. I cut the chocolate oreo cookes into four pieces and froze them. I pulled a wedge out of the freezer and ate it frozen and it was super good! I am hoping to share the fundraiser idea with our schools!

Absolutely fantastic cookies! I cannot wait to order more, which I will be very soon. The ingredients are top notch, the flavors are amazing and the texture is perfect. I am a HUGE cookie person, and these do not disappoint.

Placed my order on Wednesday and they were at my door on Friday. These cookies are huge, soft and yummy.

Cookie price is too high. Quality of cookie is poor. Tastes like they are not completely backed. Requirement to buy six cookies is unreasonable. Online ordering system could be more user friendly. Did not need customer service. Delivery was excellent. Quick and cookies were intact, cost was rather high, though. It seemed like a good idea but execution was very poor.

Cookies were very good especially when heated in the oven

Yummy! Yummy!

Awesomely good cookies. They were fabulous

Easy to place order, quickly delivered with great care and yummy!

We were at the Corn Festival this past Saturday and my youngest autistic son purchased a birthday cake batter cookie. He said it was, "Yummy! That was really good. " We will definitely order some online. They would make great Christmas gifts too.

With all the crumbles and other bakery stores popping up, I was hesitant to think that these could be something that actually tasted good and not like sugar and and thank God for me, I was wrong!! What really caught. My attention was the uniqueness of the flavors and having a filling. I then shared one of the birthday cake cookies with my kid and a couple friends. , that was my only mistake of the day!!! because after this, everybody was so shocked by how good these were that they demanded more, I legit felt like I was in a petting zoo, and the goats were flocking me🤣😂🤣 I haven’t even tried them heated yet, but I am so thankful to finally find good cookies again. I ended up buying close to two dozen. I think to share with everybody because people need to try them. I also just read the owner’s story and it makes me more than ever want to the company. My only recommendation would be at least open up one more shop close to a city, because I guarantee the overhead of hiring to ship most of the orders was taken away from profit. I recommend Pittsburgh because that’s where I’m at, but even here or Philadelphia, I think would be a great move. You’re also close the Penn State so I know there’s plenty of students with the Cookie Munchie up there. I am very very picky, especially with baked goods anymore cause I feel like they all taste less flavorful than ever and companies just add more sugar to try to overcome that. I can vouch these cookies are the only existing cookie justified to be six dollars, you could split a cookie in four and that is plenty to get your dessert fill without being nervous of the calories. Halfway this company gets bigger and expands - best of luck Russ

These are so good we tried them at a festival and I just was craving them so bad I had to order online. Flavors for the whole family they also shipped very fast

Arrived in perfect condition, with the same great taste I remember from my last purchase a year ago.

Best cookies

The best cookies I've ever eaten! They are always so fresh and so delicious!

These cookies are the absolute best thing I ever put in my mouth. My girlfriend and I literally look forward to putting a movie on at night and eating a cookie. 10/10

I first tried you at our local Lilac Festival in Rochester, NY & was blown away. After consuming the ones i purchased there, i bought more from your website. So good! 10/10

The cookies was awesome and delicious!! It has arrived on time which is great. I will definitely order again!!!

Cookies are delicious and shipping was fast

Cookies are delicious! Arrived on time, will definitely be ordering again!