The good, it’s easy to install. Seems to be pretty solid and adds a good shelf for extras. For what it is, imo it’s overpriced, but all of the shelves are. The install brackets could probably be an inch or two lower, as the tray itself is almost not accessible due to the height. Pictures of it installed in a hardtop would probably show this, I imagine why they don’t have one. I’d like to see some new bracket designed that can help with height adjustment, or make the tray slightly shorter to fit between the pillars. If that were fixed I think it would have more flexibility in the application.